Contact Us

1-800-248-7675

Send us an Email

Fill out my online form.

Our Locations

2101 Florence Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45206

Phone: 513-241-7675
Toll Free: 800-248-7675

HOURS OF OPERATION:
Monday through Friday
8:30 A.M. to 5:00 P.M.

Meet the Team

John Carroll

John Carroll

CEO

1-800-248-7675

Jennifer Agnello

Jennifer Agnello

President

513-629-9340

Bill Mauch

Bill Mauch

Chief Financial Officer

513-629-9322

Natalie Maier

Natalie Maier

Director, Human Resources

513-629-9321

Luke Boemker

Luke Boemker

Vice President, Sales Operations

513-629-9338

Shelly Brownell

Shelly Brownell

Senior Director, Employee Benefits

513-333-4420

Nelson Culp

Nelson Culp

Director, Employee Benefits
Dayton/Columbus/Athens

937-610-5744

Kim Kinnaird

Kim Kinnaird

Director, Employee Benefits
Lima/Toledo/Michigan/Indiana

567-302-2718

Jeff Lewis

Jeff Lewis

Director, Employee Benefits
Northeast Ohio

216-230-7053

Tracy Lawson

Tracy Lawson

Lead Broker Advisor
Cincinnati/Northern KY

513-629-9341

Becky Kinnaman

Becky Kinnaman

Broker Advisor
Columbus

614-763-2253

Beth Davisson

Beth Davisson

Broker Advisor
Dayton

937-610-5741

Bobby Beatrice

Bobby Beatrice

Broker Advisor
Cincinnati/Northern KY

513-629-9511

Sarah Lucas

Sarah Lucas

Broker Advisor
Cincinnati/Northern KY

513-629-9345

Liz McGuire

Liz McGuire

Account Advisor
Dayton

937-610-5742

Evangeline Barnhart

Evangeline Barnhart

Client Relations Advisor
Columbus/Athens

740-592-0341

Patti Anderson

Patti Anderson

Broker Care Specialist
Cincinnati/Northern KY

513-629-9324

Virginia Brewster

Virginia Brewster

Renewal Specialist
Cincinnati/Northern KY

513-629-9339

Andrew Ullman

Andrew Ullman

New Business Specialist
Cincinnati/Northern KY

513-458-1458

Sam Kathman

Sam Kathman

New Business Specialist

513-629-2461

Tara Tedrow

Tara Tedrow

New Business Assistant
Athens

740-592-0320

Kelly Utley

Kelly Utley

Administrative Assistant
Cincinnati/Northern KY

513-629-9347

Geoff Beglen

Geoff Beglen

Lead Account Advisor, Individual

513-629-9358

Eric Pouncy Jr.

Eric Pouncy Jr.

Broker Specialist

513-629-2396

Jessica Larkin

Jessica Larkin

Marketing and Communication Services Specialist

513-629-2382

Joyce Feinauer

Joyce Feinauer

Director, Commissions

513-629-9331

Sandy Weber

Sandy Weber

Director, Licensing

513-629-9329

Lesli Goins

Lesli Goins

Commission Specialist

513-487-5921

Tom Levine

Tom Levine

Commission Specialist

513-487-5390

Jordan Meece

Jordan Meece

Licensing Specialist

513-333-4422

Kelli Meeker

Kelli Meeker

Licensing Specialist

513-487-5937

Natalie Maier

Natalie Maier

Director, Human Resources

513-629-9321

Jamie Bryan

Jamie Bryan

Human Resources Specialist

513-487-5385

Peggy Yates

Peggy Yates

Director, Data Management

513-629-9350

Eric Pouncy

Eric Pouncy

Accounting and Operations Manager

513-629-9337

Chris Carroll

Chris Carroll

Receptionist and Operations Assistant

513-629-9334

You will be redirected to the Cornerstone Senior Marketing site.

Yes, take me there