Who We Are

Our six regional offices support more than 2,000 insurance brokers with a full array of group, individual, and ancillary/worksite health insurance products.

  • We Are Experienced

    We’ve been around the block when it comes to health insurance. Since 1985, we have been a leader in the employee benefits and individual/family health insurance industry.

  • We Are Committed to Our Community

    Just as our business relationships are important, so too is our involvement with the community. From raising funds for various charitable causes to getting our hands dirty in our own communities, we are committed to giving back.

  • We Are Family-Owned

    The Carroll family has been at the head of the table for the last 40 years, with ownership most recently being passed to siblings Annie and Ryan Carroll.

  • We Are a Cincinnati Top Workplace

    Cornerstone has been named a Top Workplace by The Cincinnati Enquirer for the last eight consecutive years.

  • We Are Local

    With six offices throughout the state of Ohio, we are never too far away.

Do You Want to Join Our Team?

Cornerstone is continuously looking for energetic and motivated individuals to join our diverse, growing team. If that sounds like you, then click the link below!

Our People

Our people are our bread and butter and the sole reason we have maintained our title of Top Workplace for the last eight years. Our continued success would not be possible without the commitment and pride our team brings with them each day.

Annie Carroll

Annie Carroll

Co-Owner

(513) 333-4434

Ryan Carroll

Ryan Carroll

Co-Owner

513-629-2466

John Carroll

John Carroll

Chairman

1-800-248-7675

Bill Mauch

Bill Mauch

Chief Financial Officer

513-629-9322

Natalie Maier

Natalie Maier

Director, Human Resources

513-629-9321

Luke Boemker

Luke Boemker

Vice President, Sales Operations

513-629-9338

Shelly Brownell

Shelly Brownell

Senior Director, Employee Benefits

513-333-4420

Nelson Culp

Nelson Culp

Director, Employee Benefits

937-610-5744

Kim Kinnaird

Kim Kinnaird

Director, Employee Benefits

567-302-2718

Jeff Lewis

Jeff Lewis

Director, Employee Benefits

216-230-7053

Tracy Lawson

Tracy Lawson

Lead Broker Advisor

513-629-9341

Becky Kinnaman

Becky Kinnaman

Broker Advisor

614-763-2253

Beth Davisson

Beth Davisson

Broker Advisor

513-813-5949

Bobby Beatrice

Bobby Beatrice

Broker Advisor

513-629-9511

Kyle Wolfe

Kyle Wolfe

Broker Advisor

513-487-5386

Liz McGuire

Liz McGuire

Account Advisor

937-610-5742

Evangeline Barnhart

Evangeline Barnhart

Client Relations Advisor

740-592-0341

Patti Anderson

Patti Anderson

Broker Care Specialist
Virginia Brewster

Virginia Brewster

Renewal Specialist
Andrew Ullman

Andrew Ullman

New Business Specialist
Kelly Utley

Kelly Utley

New Business Specialist
Tara Tedrow

Tara Tedrow

Lead Quoting and Broker Specialist
Heather Lytle

Heather Lytle

Quoting Assistant
Lindsey Rudd

Lindsey Rudd

Quoting Assistant
Geoff Beglen

Geoff Beglen

Lead Account Advisor, Individual

513-629-9358

Eric Pouncy Jr.

Eric Pouncy Jr.

Broker Specialist

513-629-2396

Jessica Larkin

Jessica Larkin

Marketing Specialist

513-629-2382

Joyce Feinauer

Joyce Feinauer

Director, Commissions

513-629-9331

Sandy Weber

Sandy Weber

Director, Licensing

513-629-9329

Lesli Goins

Lesli Goins

Commission Specialist

513-487-5921

Tom Levine

Tom Levine

Commission and Technical Specialist

513-487-5390

Jordan Meece

Jordan Meece

Licensing Specialist

513-333-4422

Kelli Meeker

Kelli Meeker

Licensing Specialist

513-487-5937

Natalie Maier

Natalie Maier

Director, Human Resources

513-629-9321

Jamie Bryan

Jamie Bryan

Human Resources and Shared Services Advisor

513-487-5385

Eric Pouncy

Eric Pouncy

Accounting and Operations Manager

513-629-9337

Chris Carroll

Chris Carroll

Receptionist and Operations Assistant

513-629-9334

How Can We Help You?

Give us a ring or shoot us an email to learn how Cornerstone can help you grow your business. Whether you’re looking for more a la carte services or you prefer the full consultative experience, we have a strategy for you.